WebDec 22, 2014 · Desk-rejected articles eventually published in other journals received fewer citations than those that went through at least one round of peer review before rejection. Of 1,008 articles in our dataset, 772 were desk-rejected by at least one of our focal-journals. round of peer review before rejection. Of 1,008 articles in our dataset, 772 were … WebApr 29, 2024 · The study provides global averages across manuscripts, and it included data about over three million manuscripts submitted in 2005-2010. From 2005 to 2010 the overall acceptance rates decreased slightly from 40,6% to 37,1%.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of ... - Research help desk
WebPNAS MS# 2013-08495RR Decision Notification. 2014-02-11. On Feb 11th we received a final round of reviews with a rejection decision by the chairman of the Editorial Board. In the reviews, Reviewer 2 continued to be positive across the board, while Reviewer 4 raised a new set of concerns, most of which were not present in the previous review. WebI recently submitted a manuscript to PNAS and was a bit confused by their review system. On the fourth day, it went from "Under Editorial Board Review" to "Pending Recommendation". From one comment on a forum, I read that this basically means … rick ferri core four
Paper Rejection: Common Reasons Elsevier Author Services Blog
WebYet reviewer 1 was clearly that person (exact same viewpoint and same wording of specific parts of their papers) and picked out every possible misunderstanding to reject the paper. Rejected (im.) Rejected (im.) Rejected (im.) Motivation: This feels like a template rejection letter without even properly reading the MS. Webleft half of Fig. 1. The rejection rate in the impunity game (M 0.317) and the rate in the private impunity game (M 0.323) were practically identical (Mann–Whitney test, z 0.28, P 0.78). And, the rejection rate in the 2 impunity games combined was significantly different (z 3.84, P 0.0001) from the rejection rate in the ultimatum game (M 0. ... WebSep 9, 2024 · Data collected by studying submissions from over 18 countries shows that rejection rates range from 22.6% to 73.4% across journals,1 while top journals are known to routinely reject over 90% of the manuscripts submitted.2 Rejection, especially desk rejection, happens to the best of us, but it is not the end of the road for researchers. rick ferri bogleheads